Jul 13 2010
Hang Down Your Head Tom Mooney, Hang Down Your Head and Cry
The United States had been watching the events in Europe in 1916, and although the isolationists remained strong, more and more people had come to the conclusion that American intervention in World War II was on the horizon. The City of San Francisco had organized a Preparedness Day Parade to support the anticipated entry of the United States into the war. This was to be the largest parade in the City’s history, some 51,000 plus marchers from over 2100 organizations including 52 bands had signed up for the 3.5 hour procession.
The parade stepped off at 1:30 on July 22,1916. At 2:06 a half an hour into the parade a dynamite time bomb concealed in a suitcase exploded on the west side of Steuart Street just south of Market Street a block away from the Ferry Building. Whoever had constructed the bomb had added heavy metal sash weights which fragmented into pieces of shrapnel augmenting the destructivness of the bomb. The explosion killed ten bystanders and wounded forty others making it the worst terrorist act in San Francisco history.
In an earlier post I noted that July is Laborfest in San Francisco, a celebration of the City’s labor history. The Preparedness Day bombing led to one of the most controversial legal proceedings in California history, the trial and conviction of labor leaders, Thomas Mooney and Warren Billings, for the bombing. Today, except for afictionados of San Francisco history, Tom Mooney is largely forgotten. But when pollsters conducted a survey in Europe in 1935, Europeans identified him as one of the four best known Americans, the others being Franklin D. Roosevelt, Charles A. Lindbergh, and Henry Ford.
Tom Mooney was born in Chicago, the son of Irish immigrants, on December 8,1882. His father was a coal miner and a militant organizer for the Knights of Labor who died of silicosis when he was 36 leaving Tom and his two siblings fatherless. Tom started work at 14 and apprenticed as a iron molder and in 1902 joined the International Molders Union. He saved his money and travelled to Europe where he encountered Nicholas Klein, a delegate to the International Socialist Congress.while visiting a musuem in Rotterdam. Mooney returned to America a committed socialist and devoted himself to the study of the works of Karl Marx.
He found work at a foundry in Stockton, California and joined the Socialist Party of America and campaigned for the presidential candidacy of Eugene V. Debs. He returned to Chicago after the election and devoted twelve hours a day to the study of socialism in a reference library. In 1909 he returned west to take a job at Idaho iron foundry. In the following year he represented the American Socialist Party at the International Socialist Congress in Copenhagen. He settled in San Francisco on his return and became a member of the Industrial Workers of the World. He married Rena Hermann in 1911 and published a small socialist newspaper in San Francisco, The Revolt, and also ran as the Socialist candidate for Sherrif of San Francisco.
The Pinkerton Detective Agency tried to frame him on a charge of transporting dynamite, but he successfully appealled a two year prison sentence to Folsom Prison. Unable to find work as a molder he became a full time union organizer including participation in a stike by the streetcar workers of the United Railroads. When one of the railroad’s towers in the San Bruno Hills was dynamited in June 1916 the railroad tried to tie him to the bombing. This was the context of Mooney’s life at the time of the Preparedness Day bombing.
Suspicion first fell on Alexander Berkman, with whom Mooney had associated, an anarchist who had relocated to San Francisco after being implicated in a bombing in New York City. Two eyewitnesses had described seeing two dark skinned men, probably Mexicans, carrying a suitcase near the bomb site. But Martin Swanson, who had tried to implicate Mooney in the earlier dynamiting charge while with Pinkerton and with the San Bruno bombing while with the Public Utilities Protective Bureau became convinced that Mooney and his assistant Warren Billing were responsible and took the claim to District Attorney Warren Fickert, the night of the Preparedness Day bombing, and went to work for the District Attorney the next day.
On July 16 Fickert charged Mooney, Billings, Israel Weinberg, Edward Nolan,and Rena Hermann with the crime. The District Attorney’s case was full of holes from the beginning. None of the eyewitnesses picked Mooney or Billings out of a line up. The conviction was almost solely based on the testimony of two men, John McDonald, an unemployed waiter, and Frank Oxman, an Oregon cattleman. They claimed they saw Billings plant the bomb at 1;50 and then saw him talking with Mooney and his wife a few moments later. A famous piece of forensic evidence completely contradicted their story. The defense produced a photo of the couple taken a mile away. A clock in the photo showed the time of 1:58. Because of the heavy traffic, it would have been impossible for Mooney and his wife to be at the scene of the bombing at 1:50
Nonetheless the jury found Mooney and Billings guilty and sentenced Mooney to death and Billings to life imprisonment. The jury acquited Rena Mooney and Israel Weinberg and Edward Nolan never came to trial.
The Federal Government became concerned about the trial and the verdict,and the Secretary of Labor William Bauchop Wilson had the Director of General Employment John Densmore look at the case. He planted a dictaphone in Fickert’s office and was able to find out that Mooney and Billings had in all probability been framed. Fremont Older reported the allegation in the San Francisco Call of November 23, 1917. Draper Hand of the San Francisco Police Department went to Mayor James Rolph to confess that he had helped frame the two men and had gotten McDonald to testify by offering him a large share of a reward. Two other men came forward to testify that Oxman was 200 miles away from the bombing site and could not have seen what he stated that he had seen.
William Stephens, the Republican Governor of California, commuted Mooney’s death sentence to life in prison, but over the next twenty years he and four other Republican governors refused to order a retrial or to release Mooney and Billings. In 1937 a group of federal legislators asked F.D.R. to intercede. When he refused, two of them introduced a resolution in the Senate asking Republican Governor Frank Merriman to pardon the two men.
Finally in November 1938 California voters elected Culbert Olson the first Democratic Governor in forty-four years and he ordered the release of Mooney and Billings. The Tom Mooney who emerged from prison was old from prison and sick with ulcers and jaundice. In his last hurrah the Sunday after his release he walked in a parade up Market Street from the Embarcadero to San Francisco Civic Center escorted by one hundred longshoremen with their hooks and a contingent of his own union, Local 164 of the International Moulders Union, behind them. He pointedly thumbed his nose a the Hearst Building at Third and Market as a protest against the press editors who had reviled him over the years. He died largely unrembered and alone on March 6, 1942 although a large funeral celebration followed at San Francisco Civic Auditorium.
No one has ever established who was resposible for the bombing. Some think it was Alexander Berkman and his anarchists. Both Mooney and Billings knew how to use dynamite and Billings had knowledge of clockwork mechanisms and became a watch repairman after his release from prison. Suspicions also centered around the radical anarchist followers of Luigi Galleani and the elusive bomb maker Mario Buda who was known to include heavy metal slugs in his dynamite time bonds to increase their deadliness. Today the bombing lives on in one of the murals in the Ricon Postal Annex, part of the rich tableaux of San Francisco labor history.






















